Thesis examiners comments

I understand it to mean reflecting in such a way as to become aware of your own beliefs. Pettigrew Archival records: Examiner 3 Heriot-Watt University, Edinburgh, Scotland Overview Mr Reekie has carried out an excellent Thesis examiners comments program to formalize and facilitate the design of digital signal; processing DSP systems.

This leads to a Thesis examiners comments of what the research in this thesis is really about and how it is investigated. I acknowledge the suggestions from the Examiner, and have made the following improvements based on the suggestions: The revised research objectives and research questions are as follows: However, in many cases, the semantic definitions are unclear.

Plagiarism In cases where plagiarism is suspected, the examiner must return the thesis and report the suspected plagiarism, citing sources of the original material that was allegedly plagiarized.

The student will be given copies of all reports at the conclusion of the defence. In response, I have taken the following actions: I have re-written the whole of Chapter 2 to clarify the relevance and the connections between the concepts in finding the research gaps, building my research objectives and developing my research questions.

The research objectives, the research gaps, and the research questions of the revised version are developed based on the enhanced literature review section 2.

Chapter 3 begins with a good perspective of dataflow history but I would point out that the discussion of phased actors should have a more detailed comparison with the I-structures used by Arvind's MIT dataflow group since Topic Four 22 Thesis evaluation reports: Objectivity of the Examination Process Once the thesis has been submitted, no one outside of GPS should attempt to communicate with the examiner s regarding the thesis, nor should the examiner s communicate with one another or with the student or the supervisor s until the examination process is complete.

Thesis examination is an object of study and researchers agree that the choice of thesis examiners needs to be handled with extreme care. To improve clarity of data analysis, the within-case analyses chapters 5, 6, and 7 in the revised version and cross-case analysis Chapter 8 have been restructured accordingly as discussed in point 4 below.

Coded data can be retrieved efficiently. More work therefore needs to be done before this thesis achieves the standard required of doctoral work.

A handbook for supervisors. Patton The theoretical framework, research objectives and research questions are re-emphasized in the methodology chapter. If the citations are sourced from more than one interviewee, the in-text reference will be interviews: However, the findings may also be applicable to developed countries, but it would require further research on the relative roles between governments and corporations.

Both examiners must pass the thesis before the examination can proceed to the Oral Defence. How does a company formulate and implement its CSR to address social issues strategically.

British Education Research Journal 21 3: It was a truly spiritual journey. The candidate makes the following claim: In response, I have conducted the following actions: In this context I am unclear if the candidate is claiming to undertake deductive research or inductive research or even understand the difference.

In this sense the treatment is incomplete and undeveloped; ideally, the methodology should be strengthened but for the purposes of this thesis a more precise summation of the contribution of this section and how it should be developed will be adequate.

Include contact details including university affiliation, address, phone number and email details. A case methodology seems appropriate but I do not agree that most prior research is quantitative.

The steps of data analysis being implemented in this study include: Examiner 1 University of Technology at Sydney Content The candidate demonstrated the ability to understand a vast area of research and clearly identify some of the problems in this area.

The section on data collection and data management section 4. How to make sense of the data collected in the pursuit of the investigation What the data contributes to an understanding of the original issue or topic The supervisor can provide feedback related to how well the argument has been articulated and whether as a result of the extended argument there appears to be inconsistencies within the argument itself.

Are we talking about education, or many employee initiatives such as volunteering, or supporting new enterprise development, or merely providing community facilities. More critique and evaluation is needed.

At the data reduction stage, I selected, focused, simplified, abstracted, and transformed the data that appeared in selected written materials to sharpen the data for further conclusion and verification. Examiner comment on the literature review in Ph.D. theses examiners’ comments, Higher Education The literature review is a crucial section of a doctoral thesis.

Examiners expect students. Introduction. When I (the first author) wrote my MA thesis and then my PhD, I had no idea what my examiners would do.

I knew that I would dispatch my thesis and then some time later it would come back with comments and a judgement, but I did not know what happened in the middle. What examiners do: what thesis students should know Clinton Golding*, Sharon Sharmini and Ayelet Lazarovitch thesis examiners get annoyed and distracted by presentation errors, and they want to read a work that is a coherent whole.

As academic readers, examiners (); or comments on the literature review in Holbrook ()). Also, the examiners' reports were more inclined to summative assessment than formative feedback, in the sense that there was a focus on the negative aspects of the thesis and an absence of praise.

When the completed examiners’reports have been returned to GPS, the procedures for Master’s theses and Doctoral theses are as follows: Master’s thesis: If the examiner has passed the thesis, GPS will send copies of the report.

The reports should also contain specific comments on those parts of the thesis that the examiners believe to require correction or amendment.

The examiners form their own independent assessments of the thesis without discussion amongst themselves or with the candidate.

Thesis examiners comments